 |
The Spin on Aspartame
20 JULY 2008 - By Lynn Stratton - healthy-holistic-living.com
If you google "aspartame," the results will take you
literally days to wade through-believe me, I know. I've been sifting
through it for days. There's more than enough information, research,
and speculation out there on the subject to fill volumes, and this
is just a small article.So rather than simply rehash everything
that has been written about aspartame (I've included some links at
the end of this article, and within it, for those who want more
information), I wanted to take a different approach. I wanted to
focus on a small part of the debate, and then follow it through to
wherever it took me.
I wanted to look at the folks who keep assuring us that it's
safe: the experts. Experts in the government, experts in the medical
field, the people who keep patting us on the head and telling us not
to worry, that if aspartame was dangerous, they'd tell us.
The problem was, I've always been something of a skeptic. The
more someone pats me on the head, the more I start looking for
something up his sleeve.
But, as skeptical as I am, what I found startled me: a concerted
effort, on the part of those at the highest levels of our government
and those at the highest levels of the medical community, to mislead
us about the safety of aspartame.
Let me be clear: We have been deceived about the safety of a
dangerous product, and all in the name of corporate profits.
* * *
Where did aspartame come from? It was first developed by the
pharmaceutical company G.D. Searle. But Searle had difficulty
getting their product approved by the Food and Drug Administration,
the federal agency responsible for making sure our food and drugs
are safe: Apparently, the monkeys and mice the substance was tested
on developed brain lesions, tumors, and seizures, and even died from
it. The company's applications for approval were rejected for 16
years, but they persisted in offering their "proof" that aspartame
was safe until the FDA finally asked the Department of Justice to
prosecute G.D. Searle for submitting fraudulent test data in their
efforts to get the substance approved. (An FDA senior toxicologist,
Dr. Adrian Gross, once told Congress, "Beyond a shadow of a doubt
aspartame triggers brain tumors.")
But then G.D. Searle, producer of aspartame, made Donald Rumsfeld
its CEO-yes, that Donald Rumsfeld. When Ronald Reagan took office
and brought Rumsfeld with him as part of his transition team, a
new
FDA commissioner was appointed immediately. In one of his first acts
as head of the federal agency, the new FDA commissioner approved
aspartame, the artificial sweetener made by the company that Donald Rumsfeld was now the head of, over the objections of the FDA
scientific board.
And here's a strange bit of trivia: When it looked like aspartame
would be approved later on for use in carbonated beverages, the
National Soft Drink Association itself objected,
saying it wouldn't be safe because aspartame is very unstable in
liquid form and breaks down into, among other things,
formaldehyde.
Monsanto bought G.D. Searle and Co. in 1985, and the NutraSweet
Company operated as part of Monsanto until 2000, when Monsanto sold
it to J.W. Childs Equity Partners, where it remains today.
| Comment: The
American human body has been known for quite some time to have
so much formaldehyde contained in the body on a normal basis,
that if the body were to lay dead, it would not begin to rot for
several days. |
And in all this time, the FDA has compiled a list of 92 symptoms
associated with aspartame consumption, including nausea, dizziness,
blindness, deafness, weight gain, and even death. And aspartame is
still here, and it's showing up in more and more products.
In fact, the Aspartame Resource Center, at www.aboutaspartame.com,
notes that it is found in more than 6,000 products worldwide. And
they should know: the Aspartame Resource Center is actually a public
relations and "information" arm of Ajinomoto, one of the world's
largest producers of aspartame, the other being the NutraSweet
Company. (Ajinomoto is also known for its other additive, monosodium
glutamate, or MSG.) The ARC site is full of cheerful information on
the safety of aspartame, and they even have a section labeled "Meet
the doctors," which lists their "medical advisory board."
In that section, the ARC says, "The Aspartame Information Center
Expert Medical Advisory Board was created to help guide the Center's
communications to health professionals and the public about
aspartame benefits, safety and role in a healthy diet. The board
members provide counsel on current medical and nutrition science, as
well as insight on tools that help address the needs of health
professionals in their work. Their backgrounds span critical areas
of medicine and science, and each has unique experience in health
and nutrition."
But, wait. Are they confused about who they are? What is this
"Aspartame Information Center" they mention? I looked it up:
www.aspartame.org. They, too, have a laundry list of "experts" they
use to back up their claims that aspartame is safe, including our
very own FDA and something called the Calorie Control Council. In
fact, the Calorie Control Council owns the Aspartame Information
Center site and is listed on the bottom of every page as the
copyright holder.
But back to the ARC. The Aspartame Resource Center offers all
sorts of "fact" sheets you can download, including one called
"Straight Answers About Aspartame." It was prepared by the American
Dietetic Association . . . and the Calorie Control Council. At the
bottom, the fact sheet notes that it has been sponsored by
aspartame.org, that is, the Aspartame Information Center, a.k.a. the
Aspartame Resource Center, a.k.a. Ajinomoto, one of the world's
biggest producers of aspartame.
Ajinomoto, in cahoots with the American Dietetic Association?
Let's see who's behind the Calorie Calorie Control Council. Here's
what their own site, at www.caloriecontrol.org, says: "The Calorie
Control Council, established in 1966 . . . represents 60
manufacturers and suppliers of low-calorie, low-fat and light foods
and beverages, including the manufacturers and suppliers of more
than a dozen different dietary sweeteners . . ."
Go further, and you'll see another site connected to the Calorie
Contol Council, called Calories Count, at www.caloriescount.com,
which lists as its sponsors . . . wait for it . . . Ajinomoto,
NutraSweet, Splenda, and Sweet 'N Low. You can take a look at their
sponsorship page here: http://www.caloriescount.com/support.html.
Because it's hard to keep the players straight in the aspartame
follies, let's recap. The folks at the FDA thought aspartame was
dangerous, so they wouldn't approve it. They changed their minds
when the president at that time and his buddy, Donald Rumsfeld, who
just happened to be the head of the company that made aspartame,
appointed a new head of the FDA. Miraculously, aspartame was
approved not long afterward, after sixteen years of
being rejected. And when we look for information on aspartame, to
allay our concerns, we find Web sites full of comforting information
showing us how safe the stuff is, written by reliable organizations
like the American Dietetic Association, and sponsored by . . .
aspartame.
Got that? Okay, but there's more. Because I was trying not to get
lost in the organizational rabbit hole, I backed out again to the
Aspartame Resource Center and its expert medical advisors. After
all, these were the medical professionals, the people who had the
scientific knowledge, not to mention the connections with both the
governmental agencies that protect our health and the largest
medical and health organizations. Surely, they were to be trusted.
Skeptical, I started with the first name on the list, and I fell
into yet another rabbit hole that seems, even now, to have no end.
In fact, I never got past that first name.
The first name on the list? C. Wayne Callaway, M.D.
I went first to his own Web site. Once you get past the
introductory quote from Hippocrates, you can find all sorts of
interesting information there. In fact, he has very helpfully posted
his entire curriculum vitae for all and sundry to see.
C. Wayne Callaway, M.D., received his medical training at
Northwestern University, Mayo Graduate School of Medicine and
Harvard University. Very impressive. He's board certified in
Internal Medicine, Clinical Nutrition, and Endocrinology, Diabetes
and Metabolism and has held academic appointments at Harvard Medical
School, Mayo Medical School, and George Washington University.
He also works with the Mayo Clinic, the National Institutes of
Health, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, and the
USDA; he was an advisor to the U.S. Surgeon General and helped
develop dietary guidelines for the USDA. He served as chair of the
Public Information Committee of the American Society for Clinical
Nutrition and the American Society for Nutrition Sciences, has been
a member of the Board of Directors of the American Board of
Nutrition, has been a committee member at the American Heart
Association, has been an advisor to the American Medical
Association.
And he's served on the editorial boards of the American Journal
of Clinical Nutrition, among other medical journals. Whew-busy man.
Want more? His publications have appeared in the Journal of the
American Medical Association, the Annals of Internal Medicine, the
Journal of the American Dietetic Association, and the International
Journal of Obesity, among others.
The separate biography on his site tells us that Dr. Callaway
"has offered his expert views on nutrition on NBC, ABC, CBS, CNN,
PBS, ESPN, and numerous affiliates, and has appeared on the
McNeill-Lehrer Newshour, the Today Show, Good Morning America, Phil
Donahue, Larry King Live, and other nationally syndicated news and
talk programs." His opinions on nutrition and health are "frequently
published in the New York Times, Washington Post, Chicago Tribune,
LA Times, and Wall Street Journal, as well as in numerous magazines
(Time, Newsweek, U.S. News & World Report, Business Week, Vogue,
Elle, Glamour, People, Self, Health, Prevention, and others)." You
know, the mainstream media.
Callaway's bio says, "Dr. Callaway is a member of the American
Society for Clinical Nutrition." And remember, we also saw that he
served as chair of the Public Information Committee of the American
Society for Clinical Nutrition. But looking for the American Society
for Clinical Nutrition takes you directly to the American Society
for Nutrition, www.nutrition.org. They publish the American Journal
of Clinical Nutrition, "the highest ranked peer-reviewed journal in
nutrition and dietetics," and the Journal of Nutrition, "which
provides the latest research on a broad spectrum of topics of vital
interest to researchers, students, policymakers and all individuals
with interests in nutrition."
Sounds impressive, until you start poking at it, as I did. If you
keep going deeper down that particular rabbit hole, you find that
the American Society for Clinical Nutrition, A.K.A. the American
Society for Nutrition, is supported by what they call "sustaining
members," which, they say, "[provide] corporate financial support
for the society's activities in education/training, scientific
programs and professional outreach." The site says that sustaining
members have "the ability to sponsor educational opportunities,
grants and other items." Oddly, they don't specify what those "other
items" might be, but I'd be willing to bet that research is one of
them.
Would you like to know who some of the sustaining members are?
Get ready: The National Cattlemen's Beef Association. Cadbury
Schweppes. Campbell Soup Company. ConAgra Foods. Dannon. Eli Lilly.
General Mills. Gerber. GlaxoSmithKline. Kellog. Kraft. Mars.
McCormick. Monsanto (of course!). The National Dairy Council.
Nestle. PepsiCo. POM Wonderful (maker of those nifty pomegranate
juices). Procter & Gamble. The Sugar Association. Unilever. Wrigley.
Wyeth.
To recap, because the players are getting a bit confusing now,
Dr. C. Wayne Callaway is a recognized expert in nutrition, such an
expert, in fact, that he testifies before Congress and appears on
national television to expound on his views on food and nutrition.
His views are published nationally, and frequently. He is, in short,
a national expert, and his views are taken very, very seriously, and
published in well respected medical journals. And he pats us on the
back and tells us not to worry, aspartame is safe.
And he works with and writes for the folks who are "supported,"
a.k.a. "paid by," the food industry that uses aspartame. Indeed, he
is a "medical expert" on the safety of aspartame, one hired by the
aspartame industry to go before the mainstream media and tell us how
safe aspartame is.
Dr. Callaway's resume lists these as government agencies that he
consults for: the Department of Health & Human Services; the
National Institutes of Health, or NIH; the National Research
Council/National Academy of Sciences; the U.S. Congress; the USDA,
and, oddly, the U.S. Postal Service, to catch us, perhaps, if we try
to send stevia through the mail.
Oh, and one more agency he consults for: the FDA. His Web site
also helpfully lists the industry folks he consults for, a.k.a. "is
paid by." They include the American Institute of Wine and Food;
Mars; Mead Johnson Nutritional Group; the Milk Industry Foundation;
the Monsanto Corporation; Nabisco, Inc.; the National Dairy Council;
the Nestle Foundation for Nutrition and Health; Ocean Spray;
Parke-Davis; Proctor & Gamble; Quaker Oats; the United Dairy
Industry.
Oh, and one more: NutraSweet.
To recap once again, a nationally recognized expert on nutrition
who says, in his extraordinarily frequent public appearances, that
aspartame is safe, is paid by Ajinomoto and NutraSweet, the two
largest producers of aspartame, to say that aspartame is safe. (And,
this may be helpful for some of you, he's also spoken about the
safety of Olestra. Just, you know, fyi.) I said earlier that we were
being misled in the name of corporate profits. Where do the profits
come in? It is projected that the U.S. market for artificial
sweeteners, with aspartame leading the charge, will be about $1.1
billion by 2010. That's in this country, only; worldwide, it's
projected to be over $3 billion. That's a lot of money for an easily
concocted chemical.
* * *
So how do you know if a product contains aspartame? The Aspartame
Resource Center says simply looking at the ingredient list will tell
you if the product contains aspartame, and indeed, the FDA requires
that aspartame be listed on the label. Right, that ARC, that FDA.
But just in case a company hasn't listed it, if the label mentions
"phenylalanine" at all, which is a component of aspartame, then the
product contains aspartame.
But you'll need to be vigilant, especially given the tiny print
on most ingredient labels. And given the propensity of aspartame to
turn up where you least expect it, such as in the vitamins you give
to your child, or your liquid antibiotics, or your Metamucil.
The bottom line is, your vigilance is the only thing standing
between you and your unwilling ingestion of a dangerous product. Our
government and our medical experts are in the very deep pockets of
the industry that makes and sells that dangerous product, and no
help is going to come from them. None.
* * *
At the top of the home page for the Aspartame Information
Center-which, don't forget, is actually Ajinomoto, one of the two
biggest producers of aspartame-we see this quote: "Few compounds
have withstood such detailed testing and repeated, close scrutiny,
and the process through which aspartame has gone should provide the
public with additional confidence of its safety."
It's attributed to the U.S. Food & Drug Administration.
Pat, pat, pat.
If you would like to learn more you may want to read other
articles on aspartame and the potential health risks associated with
its use.
Below is a list of links that you may find helpful in sorting out
the facts:
About the Author:
Lynn Stratton worked for the St. Petersburg Times as a news
archivist, copy editor and staff writer until recently, when she
started her own writing and editing business. Before that, she
taught at USF for 15 years. Originally from NYC, she spends her
spare time walking her standard poodle, Harry, and working in her
butterfly garden, where she's had 6 species of caterpillars so far
this year.
|